• Weekly Podcast
  • Scholarship
  • Call Us
    • AZ 602-531-3911
    • CA 619-777-3370
    • CO 720-636-3444
  • Text Us
    • Text 602-INJURED
Negretti Law
  • About
    • Media
  • Cases We Handle
    • Motor Vehicle Crashes
    • Diminished Value Claims
    • Electric Scooter Crashes
    • Ride Share Crashes
    • Slips and Falls
    • Dog Bites
    • Product Defect
    • Medical Malpractice
  • Our Process
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Donate
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu
Personal Injury

Tesla Autopilot Manslaughter Case Raises Larger Questions About Car Maker Liability

tesla autopilot manslaughter case raises larger questions about car maker liability

This week, Los Angeles County prosecutors filed two counts of vehicular manslaughter against the operator of a self-driving Tesla, which ran a red light, crashed into another car, and instantly killed two people.

This Tesla Autopilot manslaughter case is the first felony prosecution in the U.S. of a driver accused of causing a fatality while operating a vehicle with an engaged driver-assist system.

The fatal crash itself occurred on December 29, 2019. A Tesla Model S, driven by Kevin George Aziz Riad, who was utilizing Tesla’s Autopilot system, ran through a red light crashing into a Honda Civic that was being driven by Gilberto Alcazar Lopez. Mr. Lopez and his passenger, Maria Guadalupe Nieves-Lopez, were killed instantly.

Mr. Riad has pleaded not guilty. According to the Los Angeles Times, the family of Mr. and Mrs. Lopez will be following the criminal case closely as they pursue a civil case against Mr. Riad and Tesla.

The case raises larger questions. While there is a possibility that Mr. Riad is responsible for what occurred, what is Tesla’s share of responsibility in this crash? As the use of vehicle automation becomes ubiquitous on roadways, don’t automakers have a growing ethical, moral, and legal responsibility when their technology fails?

👉 Related Article: Who Is at Fault in a Self-Driving Car Accident?

Answers are abundant in the data extracted from vehicles involved in self-driving car crashes. However, automakers, especially Tesla, are reluctant to share that data. Even more troubling is that our government agencies aren’t holding these automakers accountable and demanding more transparency.

NHTSA, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, seems to be giving automakers a free pass when it comes to liability. Although NHTSA ordered some, but not all, automakers to report crash data on automated vehicles, it has also issued a statement saying that crashes involving automated technology are the human driver’s responsibility.

This statement insulates automakers and points the finger outward instead of inward. It shifts the responsibility paradigm away from the product and back onto the consumer in a way that is inapposite to product liability law.

Other government agencies are also failing to hold automakers responsible. The California Department of Motor Vehicles allowed Tesla to opt out of a requirement that autonomous technology companies report crashes and system failures to the agency.

Shouldn’t state and federal governments be doing everything in their power to lean in on car makers, to prevent accidents like these?

Without more transparency, we will have a hard time evolving to a place where autonomous technology is truly safe.

In his book, Factfulness, Hans Rosling surveyed airplane crashes between the 1930s through 2016. Rosling discovered that plane crash deaths had decreased significantly during that span. Probing why, he found that flight authorities across the world had met in 1944 in Chicago — the Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation — to agree to use a common form for incident reports. Once authorities agreed to share information about flight incidents, they made it possible for all participants in the entire aviation industry to learn from each other’s mistakes. Crashes involving plane fatalities have plummeted to an almost non-existent level.

If we do not learn from our past, the past will assuredly repeat itself. Tesla autopilot manslaughter cases could become commonplace.

If auto manufacturers do not voluntarily disclose data regarding self-driving car crashes, in an effort to safeguard the public, then our government agencies must demand this data.

If our government agencies won’t demand self-driving car crash data, then plaintiff attorneys must pursue this data through our judicial system. Our focus should be on bettering technology and public safety, not increasing company profits at the risk of human lives.

January 20, 2022/by Jonathan Negretti
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on Reddit
https://negrettilaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/tesla-autopilot-manslaughter-case-raises-liability-questions.webp 442 900 Jonathan Negretti /wp-content/uploads/2021/10/negretti_logo_o-1.webp Jonathan Negretti2022-01-20 23:32:112022-01-21 00:12:49Tesla Autopilot Manslaughter Case Raises Larger Questions About Car Maker Liability

Free Case Evaluation

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Link to: Get in touch

CALL US TODAY

Link to: Get in touch

ARIZONA

602-531-3911
GET DIRECTIONS

CALIFORNIA

619-777-3370
GET DIRECTIONS

COLORADO

720-636-3444
GET DIRECTIONS

The information contained on this website is intended to give general information only and not to provide advice on specific legal issues.  This information is not intended to replace legal advice. We are not responsible for changes in the law. If you need our assistance interpreting any information contained on this website, please contact us.  Negretti & Associates does not warrant the expectation of any results. Each client’s case is inherently unique and guarantee of results cannot be obtained for other clients in similar matters without referencing the specific factual and legal circumstances of each client on an individual basis.

© 2023 Negretti & Associates. All Rights Reserved. Disclaimer & Privacy Policy.

Arizona Injury Attorney | Colorado Injury Attorney | California Injury Attorney

How to Choose a Medical Malpractice Attorneyhow to choose a medical malpractice attorneyinterview with turnsignl founder jazz hamptonTurnSignl App Enables Drivers to Have Real-Time Legal Consultations
Scroll to top